WV Civil Rights Lawyer

Police Misconduct, Civil Rights Law

Important gun Rights civil lawsuit filed against Putnam County, West Virginia, and three deputies.

 

Update:  Charleston Gazette-Mail article:

https://www.wvgazettemail.com/news/putnam_county/scott-depot-man-sues-putnam-deputies-commission-after-alleged-false/article_293c3a92-be3e-53d9-9de9-d5619717376f.html

WV Record article:

https://wvrecord.com/stories/511685545-man-sues-putnam-county-commission-deputies-for-civil-rights-violations

———————————————————————————————

Yesterday we filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the Putnam County Commission, along with three of their employee deputies: Lovejoy, Donahoe and Pauley.  The suit is related to multiple searches and seizures of Michael Walker, a Scott Depot, WV resident, who was simply exercising his right to open-carry firearms in the State of West Virginia.  He has seizures, so he cannot drive.  Therefore he walks everywhere he goes, including hunting.  But when he walks with a firearm openly displayed, which is perfectly legal in West Virginia, he has been harassed by the Putnam County Sheriff’s Department.  In December of 2016, he was arrested by Deputy Lovejoy for open carrying a pistol.  He spent an entire weekend in jail without his seizure medications, and ended up hospitalized.  He was found not guilty following a trial of that illegal arrest.

Two months later, Mr. Walker knew to turn the video recorder of his cell phone on so that his next encounter would be preserved for the world to see.  This video, a portion of which is posted here:

(https://www.facebook.com/JohnBryanLaw/videos/595342300923715/)

The video shows a law enforcement officer admitting that he targets all firearms owners, including law abiding citizens, for illegal searches and seizures.  In other words, he admits to a pattern, practice and policy of depriving the rights of gun owners in Putnam County, West Virginia.  At one point, the deputy asks Walker why he needs an AR-15….

The officer, Deputy Donahoe, calls Mr. Walker a “fucking cocksucker” a few times, accuses him of being a “sovereign citizen,” and blatantly defies established federal constitutional law.

Federal law is very clear that, in open carry states, such as West Virginia, a police officer cannot perform an investigatory detention, or seizure, or “Terry Stop,” of an individual lawfully open-carrying a firearm.  Not unless they have individualized information that the specific individual is prohibited from possessing firearms, or that the individual has committed some criminal act.  They cannot walk up to you and ask for your ID, then run a background check on you, just to be sure you’re legal to carry a gun, which is what happened here.  In fact, Deputy Donahoe admitted to committing many more civil rights violations involving innocent gun owners.  He said he does it every day, and arrests people all the time on that basis.  That might perk up the ears of some public defenders in Putnam County……

If you want to know more, read the Complaint linked below.  It has all the details, and sets out the laws which were violated.

Complete text of the Complaint:

Walker v. Lovejoy, et al., Civil Action No. 3:18-cv-01523 , U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia

December 18, 2018 Posted by | Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The “Hurt” case against the West Virginia State Police and West Virginia DNR was filed, and is in the news….

5c1590d47fcdb.image_

Full Version of the Hurt Lawsuit.

Charleston Gazette-Mail article from this Sunday:

WV family’s call to police ends in excessive force lawsuit

A family from Camp Creek, in Mercer County, is alleging West Virginia State Police troopers and a Division of Natural Resources officer violated their civil rights and exercised excessive force on them after they called police in 2016 to report an armed, unstable neighbor — who later called in a fake hostage situation, stole a police cruiser from a trooper and set it ablaze — according to a federal lawsuit filed last month in the Southern District of West Virginia.

“It was just like boom, out of nowhere all of a sudden my yard was filled with them, all screaming and hollering at [Lilly],” Ronnie Hurt said…..

Wills, who was on the phone with 911 during the entire incident, heard officers yelling at her father to step off the porch with his hands up. Due to health issues and physical disabilities, she knew he needed help climbing the porch stairs, so she went outside to assist.

Within seconds of Willis stepping outside, Trooper John R. Tupper and DNR officer Marshall Richards grabbed her and her father by the arms, yanking them “violently and forcefully” face-first off the porch and onto the ground, the suit reads.

“They didn’t tell me anything, nothing at all,” Wills said. “Not to put my hands up, not to hang up the phone. I didn’t even have a chance before I was on the ground.”

One officer grabbed Wills’ phone, hung up on 911 and threw it on the ground before stepping on it with his boot, she said.

 

December 18, 2018 Posted by | Civil Liability, Excessive Force, Governmental Liability, Lawsuits | Leave a comment